Focus on Fundraising

FCS AD Roundtable: Major Gifts Q&A

By Jason Penry, Ph.D. | November 17, 2026

Monthly Column

Focus on Fundraising

On the third Tuesday of each month, Penry’s column, “Focus on Fundraising,” delivers actionable insights into major gift trends and strategies within college athletics.

How are leaders driving philanthropic success at the Football Championship Subdivision level in a rapidly changing landscape? We gathered six accomplished athletic directors to find out.

Below, they share candid insights on common fundraising misconceptions, donor engagement strategies, and what it truly takes to build meaningful support.

The panel:

  • Chasse Conque, UTRGV
  • Jude Killy, Maine
  • Josh Looney, North Alabama
  • Justin Sell, South Dakota State
  • Pauline Thiros, Idaho State
  • Nico Yantko, Murray State

The interviews have been edited and condensed for length and clarity.

1. What is the biggest misconception people have about major gift fundraising at the FCS level?

Jude Killy, Maine: I would say the biggest misconception is that it is different from anything else in Division I. Our staff follows the same process, does the same research, strategizes, and follows the donor continuum. The biggest difference, in my experience, is the pool of major gift prospects we have at the FCS level is simply smaller than at the FBS level. That means the margin for error shrinks a bit.

Josh Looney, North Alabama: The prevailing myth is that local leaders who support flagship Power Four programs won't invest with major gifts at the FCS level. In reality, some of our fiercest advocates and most generous donors are alumni of larger brands who have a relentless passion for elevating the community where they reside. In FCS communities, donors see an immediate, tangible return on their investment. They often know our student-athletes and staff personally, see the cranes in the sky, and experience firsthand how elevating the local university positively impacts the entire community.

Pauline Thiros, Idaho State: The size of your school doesn't determine the size of your vision or the capacity of your supporters. As a mid major, we have closed a healthy number of 8 figure gifts, and keep discovering more opportunities. FCS schools need to think just as big as the P4, because transformational gifts are available at every level.

Nico Yantko, Murray State: That it “can’t be done” at a school our size. Our job is to be the catalyst for the growth of our institutions, programs and communities.

“The size of your school doesn't determine the size of your vision or the capacity of your supporters.” - Pauline Thiros, Idaho State

2. What is one thing your development team does consistently that you believe has a disproportionate, positive impact on fundraising results?

Chasse Conque, UTRGV: One of our keys to success in fundraising is ensuring our donors have multiple touch points with several staff members in our department. We want our donors to feel they can go to more than just one person with questions or if they need something from our team. This not only helps distribute the workload but helps the donor feel more connected with our department. With that said, our staff must be on the same page and share a consistent message regardless of what member of our staff a donor engages with. This places a premium on our internal communication and stresses the importance of our team constantly and consistently communicating – even sometimes what may seem like a small detail or nugget of information.

Josh Looney, North Alabama: Extreme alignment between campus advancement and athletics leadership. Far too many campuses waste energy fighting internal turf wars, but we (the AD and Advancement VP) operate locked at the hip every single day. It’s a massive victory when an athletics gift officer lands a major gift for the business school, or an academic development officer closes an athletics naming opportunity. When you share vision, trust, and momentum across campus, results multiply exponentially.

Justin Sell, South Dakota State: Our development team has done a great job in stewardship of many long-time donors, while supplementing our base with new prospects. We take a special pride in going the extra mile to make sure our donors have a great experience. We play the infinite game and consistently communicate the impact of their giving. Lastly, our team understands the value of reinforcing long standing expectations around our university culture of giving...transformational over transactional.

Pauline Thiros, Idaho State: One of the most important things we do is create opportunities for meaningful, personal interaction. We communicate, we follow up, we invite people into our program, and we make sure they understand the impact of their investment. We invite a huge number of constituents behind the veil and make them part of what we are doing. It is an enormous lift, but it pays very large dividends with large and small prospects. And we do it consistently, which matters a great deal when it comes to legacy and planned gifts, usually the opportunity for most people to make the largest contribution. We have a significant number of genuine and close relationships, whether they pay financial dividends or not. Everyone knows they are important partners in our work, they understand the difference they make for student athletes, and we are very proud of that.

“We take a special pride in going the extra mile to make sure our donors have a great experience.” - Justin Sell, South Dakota State

3. How has your program successfully identified donors capable of making significant gifts when your department has limited staff, data, and research resources as compared to the power conferences?

Chasse Conque, UTRGV: Our staff does a tremendous job of showing up and carrying the banner for our athletics department. We place a premium on attending events throughout our region, leaning on our current board members and supporters to help us identify new prospects, and utilizing our current supporters to help open doors and provide warm introductions. The second part of this is how do we make our current donors feel when they engage with us – happy donors and supporters want to bring others into the fold and they will trust that we will take care of new relationships that they have helped us form.

Justin Sell, South Dakota State: One of the biggest keys to our success has been our collaboration with the SDSU Alumni & Foundation. They house prospect research, database management, and stewardship staff to support activities happening within the athletic department. Our athletic department fundraising staff treats all donors with the same level of care as major donors, which creates positive personal feelings within our development team over time. Additionally, other academic fundraisers have been helpful in sharing the athletic vision and tying in athletics development staff to help close gifts that may not fall under an athletic portfolio.

Pauline Thiros, Idaho State: We really utilize every tool at our disposal. One of those is exploiting how often staff and teams travel for competition and recruiting. In every city we visit we are reaching out to alumni we know little or nothing about and inviting engagement. A cup of coffee, attendance at the game, lunch, a home visit. Countless very capable prospects have been uncovered simply because we made the effort the reach out and learn something about them.

The largest prospects are easy to find, everyone knows them. But a significant, much larger number in fact, of prospects are highly capable but remain undiscovered because people don’t do the work to meet high numbers of people no matter their known capacity. We do this well, but we also use the traditional identification tools, events, mailing, data-mining…and we seek input from the collective knowledge of our volunteers and donors at every level.

Nico Yantko, Murray State: There’s an art and a science to everything we do, and this is certainly a great example of how we lean into relationships while maximizing the resources we do have. We guide the donors in conversation with open ended questions to get data points in our transparent solicitation process with the donors - no surprises. We have seen significant success in treating the donors as “partners” and “investors” to get them a role as we close out our $100 million capital campaign “leading the pack.”

“We have seen significant success in treating the donors as ‘partners’ and ‘investors.’” - Nico Yantko, Murray State

4. Per your experience, where can an AD's involvement create the greatest value in the process to secure major gifts?

Chasse Conque, UTRGV: Constant communication is important for us at UTRGV. I meet weekly with our entire revenue generation team to help ensure we are all communicating, collaborating, and on the same page about what is in front of us. Whether it is helping our team prospect, connecting dots, help with introductions, or jumping in to help build a more meaningful connection to our department with a prospective donor, I believe an AD can provide great value in every facet of the donor relationship with the department.

Jude Killy, Maine: This is situational. Sometimes it might be making the ask. Sometimes it might be sharing the vision. Another time it might be a quick handshake - or even staying out of the way. To me the greatest value we can have is knowing and understanding the role we can and should play that is most helpful each time and that it can be completely different each time; and that includes not being involved because a coach or another administrator can support the success of the ask and the close better.

Justin Sell, South Dakota State: Sharing rationale behind our approach to business decisions and the ever-evolving marketplace really resonates with business owners and wealthy individuals. Ensuring a consistent and simple vision that aligns with the donor base is key. Within the last year, we patiently developed our message about roster management and how SDSU would approach roster management funds, including NIL. This message was well received and allowed us to have incredible success in fundraising for rosters when many donors are not interested in just "paying players." The positive of the House Settlement was our ability to increase giving to additional scholarships, cost of attendance, and Alston funds.

Nico Yantko, Murray State: At any level, it’s the AD/CEO’s job to create the vision and communicate it to everyone. Ensuring the staff, leadership and sport programs are aligned. Once you have leadership and alignment - the investors and partners fit the bigger picture. From there you have to give them a role. For us, we don’t promise outcomes of programs, rather we communicate the ROI those dollars will have as we build a sustainable model of excellence (and new revenues).

“Sometimes it might be making the ask. Sometimes it might be sharing the vision. Another time it might be a quick handshake - or even staying out of the way.” - Jude Killy, Maine

5. What role should the head coaches play in major gift fundraising?

Jude Killy, Maine: A coordinated one. Coaches should follow the lead of administration and development personnel to find out their role and how they can help. Typically, that is selling the vision of the program and sharing insight on what success looks like for the program within the context of the department. However, making sure those efforts are coordinated with the staff is crucial. Each coach cannot ask each major gift prospect to support their program - or position themselves to do so; they need to work with administration and the development staff to craft a plan and stick to that plan. Those efforts have to be coordinated so donors and prospects are not being solicited by multiple programs, or even University divisions, at the same time.

Josh Looney, North Alabama: Head coaches are the ultimate front door for opening new relationships with prospects who have little to no previous institutional ties. While coaching tenures fluctuate, a coach’s ability to leverage their sport-specific network brings new donors directly to the athletic department’s doorstep. When a coach is in lockstep with administration on a major ask, they belong at the table to ignite that initial passion and our development team’s job is to build the stewardship that lasts long after a single season.

Pauline Thiros, Idaho State: Head coaches are best expressing the impact of philanthropy on their programs. They can best talk about how gifts make the lives of student athletes better, improve performance, get better outcomes and create a great experience. They can give real examples of real lives changed for good, and they are best at making donors feel they are inside the program experiencing the positive outcomes of their giving. It’s a critical key to growing support.

Nico Yantko, Murray State: We don’t ask our coaches to raise money, but to build genuine relationships and educate them as the “practitioners” managing the rosters and new environment of college athletics. People give to people… and we try to leverage information, access and experience through our coaches.

“Head coaches are the ultimate front door for opening new relationships with prospects who have little to no previous institutional ties.” - Josh Looney, North Alabama

6. What is the greatest untapped major gift program opportunity at your institution that will be a future focus?

Chasse Conque, UTRGV: Planned Giving! This is an area that we have talked about quite a bit and hopefully we will embark on an aggressive effort to foster more estate and planned gifts with our donor base. Education will be key, identifying donors willing to help us lead the charge through their own testimonies, and leaning on the expertise of our central advancement office will be important for this initiative to be successful.

Jude Killy, Maine: Probably like lots of other places, we need to continue to look at donors with multiple interests in the livelihood and success of the University. How can we engage them better, not just for athletics, but for all of us? The right strategy and approach with a donor in one area, who has the inclination and capacity, can increase a major gift to that same area along with others on campus, if handled thoughtfully and collaboratively, in a way that grows the University holistically.

Josh Looney, North Alabama: Scaling elite, family-friendly premium experiences while capitalizing on the NCAA’s new roster and scholarship landscape. With our brand-new on-campus venue, Bank Independent Stadium, we’ve launched premium suite and club experiences that rival the Power Four at a scaled level, transitioning local P4 fans off the highways and living-room couches into regulars at our events. Simultaneously, for donors hesitant about NIL or experiencing rev-share fatigue, lifting scholarship limits in Olympic sports gives purists a vehicle to directly fund competitive excellence while transforming a student-athlete's trajectory.

Justin Sell, South Dakota State: Our team has been studying major gift societies across athletics for the last five years. We recently launched the Yellow & Blue Leadership Society aimed at tying together our donor support throughout all areas in the department. While the $100,000 threshold has a tremendous financial impact, we have focused on multi-year commitments to assist in planning for the future. Since we have completed nearly every major facility project, our focus will shift to endowment fundraising to secure the future of generations to follow.

“We will embark on an aggressive effort to foster more estate and planned gifts with our donor base.” - Chasse Conque, UTRGV

About the Author

Dr. Jason Penry has over 20 years of experience in consulting. His firm, Penry Advisors, provides Group of 6 and FCS-level leaders with the structure, strategic guidance, and confidence to unlock greater major gift potential in an ever-changing college athletics landscape.

Penry was the second-ever holder of the James W. Aston ’33 University Chair in Institutional Development, established in 1985, at Texas A&M University. He spent over a decade in university leadership as the chief advancement officer at two other universities: Angelo State University in the Texas Tech System and Arkansas State University.

Driven by a collaborative, team-first approach, Penry successfully engineered record-breaking fundraising years in 11 of his 13 years in philanthropic leadership roles.

External Contributor

Non-Staff Writer/External Contributor

Next
Next